The following list features the most overrated player currently on each of the 32 teams in the National Football League as well as each franchise’s most overrated player in team history. This list was curated by the staff on the Alan Michael Show who would like to remind our readers that just because a player is overrated, it does not mean they are not a good player!
| TEAM | CURRENTLY MOST OVERRATED | ALL TIME MOST OVERRATED |
| COWBOYS | EZEKIAL ELLIOTT | TONY ROMO |
| REDSKINS | JOSH NORMAN | JOE THEISMAN |
| GIANTS | SAQUAN BARKLEY | RON DAYNE |
| EAGLES | MIKE WALLACE | RON JAWORSKI |
| STEELERS | MAURKICE POUNCEY | HINES WARD |
| BROWNS | JOSH GORDON | PEYTON HILLIS |
| BENGALS | ANDY DALTON | TJ HOUSHMANZADEH |
| RAVENS | JOE FLACCO | JOE FLACCO |
| VIKINGS | KIRK COUSINS | HERSCHEL WALKER |
| LIONS | TEEZ TABOR | NDAMUKONG SUH |
| BEARS | LEONARD FLOYD | WILLIAM PERRY |
| PACKERS | CLAY MATTHEWS | CLAY MATTHEWS |
| COLTS | ANDREW LUCK | DWIGHT FREENEY |
| TEXANS | JADAVEON CLOWNEY | DAVID CARR |
| TITANS | BRIAN ORAKPO | CHRIS JOHNSON |
| JAGUARS | MALIK JACKSON | DAVID GARRARD |
| CARDINALS | DAVID JOHNSON | CARSON PALMER |
| SEAHAWKS | KAM CHANCELLOR (RETIRED) | SHAUN ALEXANDER |
| RAMS | AQIB TALIB | JIM EVERETT |
| 49ERS | JIMMY GAROPPOLO | COLIN KAEPERNICK |
| CHIEFS | SAMMY WATKINS | LARRY JOHNSON |
| CHARGERS | KEENAN ALLEN | DAN FOUTS |
| BRONCOS | CASE KEENUM | BILL ROMANOWSKI |
| RAIDERS | DEREK CARR | TIM BROWN |
| PATRIOTS | TOM BRADY | TEDY BRUSCHI |
| DOLPHINS | DANNY AMENDOLA | MERCURY MORRIS |
| JETS | ROBBY ANDERSON | BART SCOTT |
| BILLS | SHAQ LAWSON | DON BEEBE |
| BUCS | JAMEIS WINSTON | MIKE ALSTOTT |
| PANTHERS | LUKE KUECHLY | DESHAUN FOSTER |
| FALCONS | DEVONTA FREEMAN | MIKE VICK |
| SAINTS | TERRON ARMSTEAD | BOBB HEBERT |